|
Describing his music
as rootsy-pop, Minneapolis's Dan Israel says he made a conscious
effort at keeping the "pop element real out front"
on Love Ain't a Cliché. The result is a collection
of melodic, hook-driven tunes. Pop. But this ain't no Britney
Spears. The back beat from the rhythm section of drummer David
J. Russ and Kris Bowring on bass is elemental rock and roll.
Israel's lyrics are too smart to lump with today's all-flash-no-substance
pop music. It's pop, but it's no "Oops! I Did it Again."
It's Pure Pop for Now People, although Dan Israel ain't
Nick Lowe. But if you don't hear echoes of Elvis Costello, you
just ain't listening.
At times Israel's vocals resemble Costello's and, like Costello,
Israel doesn't sacrifice listen-ability for substance, saying
"it's not a song until it has some kind of hook . . . but
I also didn't want it to be fluff." Costello's stylistic
influences on Israel are readily apparent. However the life
experiences of a Brit aren't the same as an upper mid-western
boy. Ultimately Dan Israel ain't nothing but Dan Israel.
When you get your own copy of Love Ain't a Cliché
(with artwork parodying a box of those conversation heart
candies you can't escape on Valentine's Day) and ponder the title,
don't jump to the same conclusions I did. It may be a concept
album, at least in the sense that you can detect a common theme,
but there's no reason to start mumbling about Paul McCartney
or "Silly Love Songs." Book. Cover. Ring any bells?
Years ago my wife quoted a Barbra Streisand lyric, something
about people needing people. My now ex-wife (quoting Streisand
didn't help) was right. Apparently Dan Israel agrees. The underlying
theme of Love Ain't a Cliché isn't just that people
need people, but that people disappoint. Even though others
don't meet our expectations and we fall short of theirs, we persevere
because life as a hermit is no life at all. You won't find any
silly, starry-eyed love songs here. "Feet in the Water,"
one of the few tunes that might be called a love song, comes
from a place that's real. It doesn't ignore the high of new
love ("With your feet in the water/ I try not to act like
a fool/ with your feet in the water/ I feel like I'm back in
grade school/ with a secret crush on you") but also acknowledges
that sometimes things change.
And if it ever gets so dark that we must move apart
If there is no way to end a tear
I hope we're satisfied, that we desperately tried
And we never conceded to despair
With your feet in the water, we seem like two halves of
a whole
Seeing you out there, I'm feelin' a tug on my soul
And if we ever are pulled apart, and can't find a way to restart
Think you should know, it was my heart that you stole
Love-gone-bad songs are often as clichéd as the sappy,
ain't-love-grand ballads. Israel avoids the clichés.
When love goes bad he's not "Lost Without Your Love"
or (sorry Bread fans) singing that he's "Down on My Knees."
He's not cold and uncaring, but does take a cold, hard look
at the situation. He may decide "there is no way I can
fix this/ it's just too dismantled sent down the line/You can
paint it however you want/but you're still on your side and I'm
on mine." Even though he "Don't Feel Like Laughing,"
he's realistic and moves on. On "Jump Through the Rings,"
his conclusion may seem like a typical love song cliché,
"I'd jump through the rings for you any time/ I'd run way
out to the end of the earth/ So you could see what my love is
worth." However lines like "you never gave me anything
but love/ but sometimes I need a little more" and "sometimes
it seems I could be led astray/ by some shiny fool's gold"
keep the tune anchored in what's honest and real rather than
floating into idealized cliché.
"Overloaded," the cut that provides the disc's title,
is only marginally about love. Instead it takes aim at so called
friends and the hipster crowd that's a part of the music scene
in Minneapolis and everywhere else. ("I don't need no cool
friends who can't deign to talk to me / I don't need someone
who goes and turns on me / Hangin' round the hip ones, tryin'
to be noticed / I'm feelin' just a little overloaded")
Only addressing love in the final verses by explaining what it's
not.
You're so stuck, so fucked up, starstruck and out of tune
Better regroup, short-circuit the loop, find some sanity soon
I just need a good friend, to stick around with me
Don't need a harem or dynasty
'Cause love ain't a cliché, obsolete, or outmoded
And I'm feeling' just a little overloaded
"Friend in this Town" treads the same ground as
"Overloaded." When Israel sings about "sacrificing
it all for no return" and "losing's worse when so many
winners suck," it's ostensibly about the music industry.
But his feelings are universal, applying just as well to whatever
cutthroat business you work in.
Lovers, friends, and work colleagues figure prominently in
most of our lives, but our first lasting attachments were with
family. You can't choose 'em and you can't divorce 'em. Maybe
you even need them. There are alternative interpretations, but
I hear "Hey Kid" as reaching out to a younger sibling.
"If you know, how much I'd like to take back, all the teasing
and the mean, mean jibes, let's face the facts, sometimes I was
a big jerk." And surely "Wasn't Lost on Me" is
doing the same to a parent.
You talked me up, and calmed me down and kept my head on
straight
You navigated through each trial with the patience of a saint
And if I seemed to look beyond your love and generosity
Despite the hurtful things I've done it wasn't lost on me
If you're as sick as I am of songs written while looking through
John Conlee's "Rose Colored Glasses" but find the J.
Geils Band's "Love Stinks" a little too cynica,l then
rush out and buy Love Ain't a Cliché. Dan Israel
and the Cultivators understand just how you feel.
* Visit Dan and the Cultivators at www.thecultivators.com for purchase options
and more.
Contact Al Kunz at kunz-at-rockzilla.net
|